The effect of host plant on larval survivorship of the Alaskan swallowtail butterfly ( Papilio machaon aliaska )

The Alaskan swallowtail butterfly, Papilio machaon aliaska (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), uses three plant species as host plants. Cnidium cnidiifolium (Turcz.) Schischk. belongs to the family Apiaceae, the ancestral host-plant family of the P. machaon group. Artemisia arctica Less. and Petasites frigidus (L.) Franch, in contrast, belong to the distantly related Asteraceae family and were colonized relatively recently by this group of butterflies. Previous work has shown that larval survival is highest on the novel host plants when natural enemies are present in the field. Here I examine whether P. m. aliaska fitness varied when individuals were reared on the three host plants in a common environment, free of environmental and ecological complications such as predation. I collected 12 P. m. aliaska females and measured their reproductive success when their progeny were reared on each of the three host plants. I assessed larval fitness on each of the hosts by recording the percentage pupation and percentage emergence as well as by measuring pupal mass. I found that larvae reared on the ancestral host plant, C. cnidiifolium , had higher fitness than did larvae reared on either of the novel host plants, A. arctica or P. frigidus . Larvae reared on C. cnidiifolium were more likely to pupate, achieved a greater pupal mass, and had higher emergence rates than larvae reared on the novel hosts. I interpret these results to mean that, in the absence of predation, the ancestral host plant is a better host for P. m. aliaska larvae than either novel host and I contend that this result does not appear to support the hypothesis that P. m. aliaska populations in central Alaska are divided into host races.